Bullymake Reviews
Bullymake has an overall rating of 4.0 based on 11 reviews. Customer feedback on Bullymake is mixed: Bullymake reviewers highlight positive aspects like durable toys, variety of options, great for heavy chewers, excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to dog owners looking for tough toys, pet parents of aggressive chewers, individuals seeking subscription services for pet supplies. However, Bullymake is often criticized for its higher price point, limited toy sizes, occasional shipping delays, some toys not suitable for all dogs.
11 reviews
5 Stars
5
4 Stars
2
3 Stars
1
2 Stars
2
1 Star
0
How would you rate Bullymake?
All Bullymake Reviews (11)
joe1978
May 30, 2026
"Finally Something That Holds My Dog’s Attention"
My pit mix actually seems to stay interested in these toys, which doesn’t happen too often. He can get bored quickly with other stuff, but he keeps going back to the chew pieces. The box arrived in good shape, and he was excited about it, so I’d say it was a solid buy overall.
0
Reply
michael1996
May 21, 2026
"Had a bad feeling about the support experience"
The box itself was totally fine, no real complaints there. But something just felt off once I had to contact support. They took days to get back to me, and even when they did, my issue still wasn’t really fixed. I was hoping it would be a quick thing, but it ended up being frustrating.
0
Reply
hello_brandy397
May 07, 2026
"Customization was kind of disappointing"
I was excited about being able to pick things based on my dog’s preferences, but it didn’t feel all that personalized. I literally took the time to mark what he doesn’t like, and we still ended up with toys and treats that weren’t a great fit for him.
The box itself wasn’t terrible or anything, it just didn’t feel worth it for us if the preferences aren’t really being followed. Maybe it works better for other dogs, but I was definitely a little let down
The box itself wasn’t terrible or anything, it just didn’t feel worth it for us if the preferences aren’t really being followed. Maybe it works better for other dogs, but I was definitely a little let down
0
Reply
gloriasteed0701
April 22, 2026
"Good value, good value for sure"
My dog destroys toys so fast, like seriously so fast, but this bullymake box has actually been worth it. The toys are really tough and the treats are a nice size too. I feel like I’m getting more here than I would buying stuff at the store for the same amount of money.
0
Reply
rita_Prado74
April 03, 2026
"I’ve ordered from Bullymake a handful of..."
I’ve ordered from Bullymake a handful of times now, and the shipping has just been easy, which I appreciate more than I expected. The boxes show up when they’re supposed to, I haven’t had anything go missing or randomly get delayed, and I’m not sitting there refreshing tracking wondering what’s going on. It’s just nice when something actually works the way it says it will. So yeah, no complaints from me so far.
0
Reply
evelynlopez1265
March 24, 2026
"I liked that they actually showed me..."
I liked that they actually showed me the renewal price before charging my card. Felt straightforward and No sketchy billing stuff
0
Reply
JohnRosenbeck_41
February 25, 2026
"Finally, a subscription that doesn’t make pausing a whole ordeal"
I wish more subscriptions worked like this. I needed to pause for a bit and it was actually easy, no endless menus, no guilt-trippy popups, no ridiculous hoops to jump through. Just paused it and moved on with my day. Why is that so rare?
0
Reply
TerriParks_25
February 11, 2026
"My dog gets excited for these"
These treats have been a nice little find for us. My dog gets excited every time I grab the bag, so that’s always a good sign. Some flavors seem to be a bigger hit than others, but overall they seem like good quality and I haven’t had any issues. I do wish the bags were a bit bigger, though. I’d say they’re worth trying if your dog likes variety.
0
Reply
Cory.commons
February 08, 2026
"Replacement went smoothly"
One of the toys got chewed up way quicker than I expected, like really quick, but the replacement process was fine. I reached out and they sent a new one without making it a big hassle. It did take a few days to show up, but overall I’m still happy with how they handled it.
0
Reply
JackCarrera
December 10, 2025
"Decent toys, but they really should last longer"
I got a couple of boxes for my dog because he’s a serious chewer, i’m annoyed. Some of the tougher toys held up okay, especially the hard ones, but a few were destroyed way faster than they should’ve been. For what they charge, I expected better, not this hit-or-miss stuff. It feels like they know dogs chew and still toss in toys that clearly can’t handle it. Not the worst purchase ever, but I’m definitely disappointed.
0
Reply
Have a question about Bullymake?
Log in to ask your Bullymake question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
